| Games Played |
105 - Todd DeBerry (1985-89) 105 - Tim Llewellyn (1985-89) 105 - Scott Powers (1994-97) |
| Most Points |
Career: 2,237 - Jim Upperman (1964-68) Season: 733 - Ramsey Yeatts (1987-88) Game: 56 - Kyle Williford (1/16/02 vs. Roanoke) |
| Most Field Goals |
Career: 890 - Jim Upperman (1964-68) Season: 270 - Ramsey Yeatts (1987-88) Game: 23 - Bill Burkholder (2/9/52 vs. R.P.I.) |
| Consecutive FG Made |
21 - Shane Burnette (1999-2000) |
| Most Field Goal Attempts |
Career: 1,735 - Jim Upperman (1964-68) Season: 509 - Jim Upperman (1964-68) |
| Best Field Goal Percentage |
Career: 67.1 - Tim Llewellyn (1985-89) Season: 50.9 - Jim Upperman (1967-68) Game: 100.0 - Shane Burnette (11-for-11, 11/30/99 vs. Villa Julie) |
| Most 3-Pt. Field Goals Made |
Career: 199 - Jeff Berry (1990-94) Season: 85 - Ramsey Yeatts (1987-88) Game: 9 - Dominic Trawick (1/26/08 vs. Guilford) |
| Most 3-Pt. Field Goal Attempts |
Career: 510 - Jeff Berry Season: 159 - Ramsey Yeatts (1987-88) Game: 15 - Dominic Trawick (1/26/08 vs. Guilford) |
| Best 3-Pt. Field Goal Percentages |
Career: 49.8 - Ramsey Yeatts (1986-88) Season: 53.4 - Ramsey Yeatts (1987-88) Game: 100 - Ramsey Yeatts (4-for-4 vs. Shenandoah, 11/24/87); Todd DeBerry (4-for-4 vs. Lynchburg, 1/20/89) |
| Free Throws Made |
Career: 517 - Brad Harrington (1996-2000) Season: 168 - Jim Ellis (1966-67) |
| Consecutive FT Made |
48 - Brad Harrington (1997-98) |
| Free Throw Attempted |
Career: 673 - Brad Harrington (1996-00) Season: 214 - Jim Ellis (1966-67) |
| Best Free Throw Percentage |
Career: 83.0 - Ramsey Yeatts (185-for-223, 1986-88) Season: 86.8 - Todd DeBerry (79-for-91, 1988-89) |
| Rebounds |
Career: 1,112 - Tom Wright (1972-76) Season: 355 - Tom Wright (1975-76) Game: 28 - Bob Boyle (2/5/70 vs. Shepherd) |
| Assists |
Career: 561 - John Curry (1985-88) Season: 282 - John Curry (1987-88) Game: 17 - John Curry (2/88 vs. H-SC) |
| Blocked Shots |
Career: 193 - Kyle Williford (1998-2002) Season: 67 - Kyle Williford (2000-01) |